From Barry Hott’s presentation at Foxwell Meet-Up NYC
Why It Matters
It’s easy to spend Q4 tweaking campaign structure when the real levers are creative, offer, price, product, and website. Barry Hott’s point is that Meta’s algorithm is better at delivery than most of us give it credit for, so the job is to simplify, consolidate, and give new creative a fair shot with minimums and cost caps. A low CPA often just means an ad set is picking up easy wins from warm audiences, so the real test is whether a creative can spend and sustain at scale. His Q4 advice is equally practical: a strong, simple on-site offer can lift every ad, even when the creative never mentions the sale. And since a small homepage change, a stockout, or a shifting SEO ranking can swing ROAS and CPA overnight, the website deserves the same monitoring as the ad account.
Who This Is For
Built for Founders members running Meta ads, especially media buyers and creative strategists who are rethinking campaign structure or creative testing before Black Friday. Most useful if you’re debating CBO vs. ABO, wondering whether you need separate sale creative for BFCM, or finding that your lowest-CPA ads can’t actually scale.
Throughout his presentation, Barry emphasized that the real differentiators in ad performance are creative, offer, price, product, and website, not campaign structure itself. He joked that he trusts “the machines” more than ever.
Trust the System, But Use Your Levers
Barry’s core thesis is that while campaign structure (CBO vs. ABO, etc.) gets a lot of attention, it’s not the reason brands win. He encourages marketers to simplify their setups, consolidate campaigns, and let Meta’s algorithm do what it does best: optimize delivery. But he also recommends setting minimums and cost caps on new ad sets as a way to ensure new creative gets a fair shot. Once an ad has enough data, he removes those minimums. If it doesn’t keep spending, it’s time to move on.
He talked a lot about the difference between what looks like performance (low CPA, high ROAS) and what can actually scale. Barry warned that warm audiences, retargeting, and niche ad sets might show great CPAs but often can’t spend at volume. He wants to see which ads Meta “wants” to spend on because that’s the real sign of scalable creative.
CBO, Cost Caps, and Overlap
Barry cited his own evolution from ABO to CBO as proof that marketers should be willing to change their minds when the data shifts. He explained that CBO, with smart use of cost caps, allows Meta to allocate budget efficiently and avoid the traps of manual overlap and budget smearing.
He also highlighted a key misconception: just because an ad set has a lower CPA doesn’t mean it’s the best place to scale. Sometimes those low-CPA ad sets are just picking up easy wins from warm audiences. The real test is whether your creative can spend at scale. Barry’s advice is to use cost caps as a “control knob,” and set the caps high enough to let spending happen, then dial them down if performance deteriorates.
In your first hour as a member, you’ll unlock 12+ hours of Meta ad training, $6,500 worth of premium courses, and a Slack of 600+ marketers who answer questions around the clock.
Testing, Metrics, and Human Factors
Barry made a practical case for organizing creative tests as new ad sets rather than dumping everything into existing sets. Not only does this make optimization easier, but it also helps teams understand what’s working. He wants marketers to focus on campaign-level performance, not just ad-level CPAs. The question isn’t, “Which ad has the lowest CPA?” but “Which creative can actually spend, scale, and sustain performance?”
He also reminded us not to ignore the impact of negative feedback and comments. Sometimes a single bad comment can tank an ad’s performance, and he recommends tools to monitor and hide negative comments (likening it to graffiti on a billboard).
Don’t Forget About the Website
One of the most eye-opening parts of Barry’s talk was his insistence that website changes can make or break ad performance. He shared real-world stories (including from his work with Nuts.com and Tushy) where minor homepage changes, product availability, or even shifting SEO rankings had massive effects on ROAS and CPA. His advice: monitor your site for changes as closely as you monitor your ad account.
Black Friday/Cyber Monday: Let the Offer Do the Heavy Lifting
Regarding Q4, Barry had some controversial but evidence-backed advice: you don’t necessarily need to run “sale” ads for your big promotions. He’s run multi-million-dollar campaigns where the ads stayed evergreen, but the site experience and offer changed. The urgency and value of the on-site offer did the heavy lifting, and performance soared, even when the creative didn’t mention the sale at all. The lesson: a strong offer lifts all ads.
He also cautioned against convoluted or confusing offers. The simpler and more valuable your site offer, the better your campaign will perform across all creative.
Final Thoughts: Simplify, Trust (But Verify), and Focus on What Matters
Barry closed by encouraging everyone to simplify their accounts, consolidate campaigns, and trust Meta’s optimization, while staying vigilant about the factors you can control: creative, offer, and website experience. He advised excluding existing customers from prospecting campaigns, testing new structures now (before Q4 madness), and not being afraid to try new things, even if it means being wrong sometimes.
We were left with a renewed focus on the fundamentals. Barry reminded us that it’s not about hacking the algorithm or chasing the latest tactics. It’s about giving great creative and offers the best chance to win, monitoring the whole funnel (not just the ads), and letting the system do its job, while keeping a human eye on what matters most.
Big thanks to Barry for a session packed with real-world wisdom, humor, and actionable advice. If you missed it, hopefully, this recap helps you rethink your Q4 strategy and creative testing!
Want Barry Hott's full talk?
Replay · Foxwell Founders NYC 2026
Creative Testing Structure and Q4 Optimization
Why he now runs CBO with cost caps, how to judge new batches by campaign spend instead of single-ad CPA, and how he ran a big sale without one sale ad. It's one of 8 sessions in our Q4 Media Buying Crash Course, recorded live in New York.
